Boston · Cambridge · Massachusetts

Real estate, government, the courts, Harvard and Old Boston, every Sunday and all week.

Boston, at a civilized pace.

Boston Sunday by email

New stories from every section, free in your inbox.

Sign up free →

The First Circuit won’t order Maine to exempt a religious objector from school vaccines, for now. The Supreme Court may be next.

In a 2–1 order on Nov. 3, the First Circuit refused to let a Maine father’s unvaccinated son back into public school while his religious-freedom appeal goes on. Here is what the judges said about Yoder, Mahmoud and a century-old Massachusetts case, and why two petitions already at the Supreme Court matter.

The granite Edward T. Gignoux U.S. Courthouse in Portland, Maine, with autumn trees along the sidewalk and a flagpole at the corner

The First Circuit Court of Appeals has refused, for now, to order Maine to let a religious objector’s son back into public school without the vaccines the state requires. The vote was two to one, and the dissent was pointed. The group that brought the case says it will go next to the Supreme Court, where two other petitions about religious exemptions from school vaccine rules are already waiting.

The order came on Nov. 3, Election Day, in We The Patriots USA, Inc. v. Makin, No. 26-2035. Judges Gustavo A. Gelpí and Seth R. Aframe denied an injunction pending appeal. Judge Joshua Dunlap would have granted it. The appeal itself goes on, and the plaintiffs say their merits brief is already filed, but Maine’s law stays in force against the family while it is decided.

Keep reading. Enter your email below to unlock the rest of this story, free. To support Boston Sunday’s reporting, subscribe for $16.99 a month or $169.99 a year.

Subscribe to continue reading

Subscribe to get access to the rest of this post and other subscriber-only content.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@bostonsunday.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Free newsletter

Get Boston Sunday by email

New stories from every section, free in your inbox.